Is COVID-19 An Excuse To Not Perform Under a Contract?

  • Mar 24, 2020
  • COVID-19
  • Colin H. Hargreaves

As more and more businesses slow down or close up due to the COVID-19 pandemic, business expectations that seemed reasonable just a few weeks ago may be difficult or even impossible to meet now.

As we face continuing disruptions and possible mandatory quarantines, businesses are wondering about their obligations under previously executed contracts. More specifically, many companies are wondering what their rights are in the event of their, or another party’s, nonperformance or inability to perform under a contract.

The first step to answer this important question is to review the governing contract to determine whether there are any provisions that cover unforeseen delays or nonperformance. Such provisions are typically referred to as force majeure, acts of God, impossibility, or impracticability provisions.

Force Majeure

A force majeure provision, for example, allows a party—under certain situations—to delay or excuse nonperformance under a contract due to unforeseen circumstances. While there is little question that a global pandemic is an unforeseen circumstance, the party that will ultimately bear the risk and liability for any resulting delay or nonperformance will be determined by the specific language used in the controlling agreement.

Therefore, whether the COVID-19 pandemic will be considered a force majeure will depend upon the contractual language previously agreed to by both parties. Some courts have previously held that prior similar outbreaks were force majeure events. However, it is important to note that any prior legal decision will depend on the specific language of the agreement and the applicable law of the jurisdiction.

Another consideration is to review any business insurance that your organization may have in the event there are any business interruption provisions, or other similar provisions covering such inabilities to perform. In some cases, insurance policies have similar language that will provide some protections.

Bottom Line

Force majeure provisions can either be a blessing or a curse depending on what side of the contractual language your company is on. These types of provisions vary greatly in scope and allocation of risk. Therefore, it is crucial that you review any contracts with your legal counsel in order to better understand your specific situation.

For all of the latest critical COVID-19 information for employers, check our continually updated FAQ’s by clicking on the banner headline at the top of the Felhaber Larson web page.